What should one look for when assessing the effectiveness of an argument in a text?

When assessing the effectiveness of an argument in a text, it's crucial to focus on the clarity and relevance of the evidence provided. Strong arguments are typically supported by solid evidence that directly relates to the claims being made. Clear evidence helps the reader understand how the data or examples substantiate the argument, making it more persuasive and credible. If the evidence is vague or does not connect logically to the thesis or main point, the argument may not hold weight. Thus, evaluating how well the evidence supports the argument is key to determining its overall strength.

In contrast, considering the diversity of topics covered can be interesting but doesn't inherently assess the argument's quality. Emotionally neutral language can indicate an objective approach, but effective arguments often use a mix of emotional appeal and logical reasoning. Finally, while an author's personal opinions can add context, they do not alone validate the strength of an argument unless supported by strong evidence.